Top 20 Insurance Providers in Fayetteville

Fayetteville, North Carolina, boasts a diverse array of insurance providers catering to the varied needs of its residents. Below is a comprehensive list of 50 top insurance providers in the area, each accompanied by a detailed profile and review.

1. Callahan & Rice Insurance Group Inc

Company Summary: Established in 1966, Callahan & Rice Insurance Group Inc has been a cornerstone in Fayetteville's insurance landscape. As an independent agency, they offer a broad spectrum of insurance products, including auto, home, business, life, and health insurance. Their consultative approach ensures clients receive tailored solutions that best fit their needs.

Official Website: https://www.callahanrice.com/

Physical Address: 129 Franklin St, Fayetteville, NC 28301

Contact Number: +1 910-484-6171

Email ID: info@callahanrice.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 20

Year Founded: 1966

Founder Name: John Callahan and Robert Rice

Number of Reviews: Over 50 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Primarily serves Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Personalized service, a wide range of insurance products, and a consultative approach

List of Services: Auto, home, business, life, and health insurance

Company Highlights: Over five decades of service in the Fayetteville community

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate their friendly and professional environment, noting that agents provide excellent customer service and tailored insurance solutions.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized as a trusted independent insurance agency in North Carolina

Review: Callahan & Rice Insurance Group Inc stands out for its long-standing commitment to the Fayetteville community. Their personalized approach and comprehensive service offerings make them a preferred choice for many residents seeking reliable insurance solutions.

2. AI Insurance

Company Summary: AI Insurance is dedicated to providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. Their team of experienced agents works closely with clients to ensure optimal coverage.

Official Website: https://aiins.us/

Physical Address: 226 Rowan St, Fayetteville, NC 28301

Contact Number: +1 910-223-3066

Email ID: info@aiins.us

Number of Employees: Approximately 15

Year Founded: 2005

Founder Name: Michael Anderson

Number of Reviews: Over 30 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding regions

Benefits: Customized insurance plans and dedicated customer support

List of Services: Auto, home, business, and life insurance

Company Highlights: Known for their prompt claim processing and customer-centric approach

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients commend AI Insurance for their responsiveness and ability to tailor policies to individual needs.

Certifications and Awards: Certified independent insurance agency

Review: AI Insurance has built a reputation for personalized service and flexibility in policy offerings. Their commitment to understanding client needs ensures comprehensive coverage and peace of mind.

3. RK Prater - State Farm Insurance Agent

Company Summary: RK Prater has been serving the Fayetteville community as a State Farm agent, offering a range of insurance products backed by a nationally recognized brand.

Official Website: https://ronaldprater.com/

Physical Address: 1490 Clinton Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28312

Contact Number: +1 910-483-5111

Email ID: ronald.prater.bxg8@statefarm.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 10

Year Founded: 2010

Founder Name: Ronald "RK" Prater

Number of Reviews: Over 25 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and neighboring areas

Benefits: Access to State Farm's extensive resources and personalized agent support

List of Services: Auto, home, renters, life, and business insurance

Company Highlights: Strong community involvement and personalized service

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients appreciate RK Prater's professionalism and the ease of managing policies through his office.

Certifications and Awards: Licensed State Farm agent

Review: RK Prater offers the reliability of State Farm's products combined with personalized local service, making him a trusted choice for many in the Fayetteville area.

4. Olde Fayetteville Insurance

Company Summary: Serving Fayetteville and Cumberland County since 1955, Olde Fayetteville Insurance is an independent agency licensed with over 30 health and life insurance carriers. They provide personalized insurance solutions, ensuring clients receive coverage tailored to their specific needs.

Official Website: https://oldefayettevilleinsurance.com/

Physical Address: Not specified

Contact Number: Not specified

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: 1955

Founder Name: Not specified

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and Cumberland County

Benefits: Access to a wide range of top-rated insurance carriers, personalized service

List of Services: Health and life insurance

Company Highlights: Over six decades of service in the community

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Not specified

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: Olde Fayetteville Insurance's long-standing presence in the community underscores their commitment to providing reliable and personalized insurance solutions. Their extensive network of top-rated carriers ensures clients have access to a variety of options tailored to their needs.

5. Warren Insurance Group - A Mike Warren Agency

Company Summary: Warren Insurance Group offers a range of insurance products to meet the diverse needs of their clients. Their experienced agents are dedicated to providing personalized service and comprehensive coverage options.

Official Website: https://warreninsgroup.com/

Physical Address: 1909 Bragg Blvd Ste 102A, Fayetteville, NC 28303

Contact Number: +1 910-222-2588

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: Not specified

Founder Name: Mike Warren

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Personalized service, comprehensive coverage options

List of Services: Various insurance products

Company Highlights: Experienced agents dedicated to client satisfaction

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Not specified

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: Warren Insurance Group, under the leadership of Mike Warren, is committed to providing personalized insurance solutions. Their experienced agents work closely with clients to ensure comprehensive coverage that meets individual needs.

6. Hurley Insurance Group

Company Summary: Hurley Insurance Group is dedicated to offering tailored insurance solutions to their clients. With a focus on personalized service, they strive to meet the unique needs of each individual and business they serve.

Official Website: https://hurleyinsurancegroup.com/

Physical Address: 1653 Owen Dr, Fayetteville, NC 28304

Contact Number: +1 910-221-3500

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: Not specified

Founder Name: Not specified

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Tailored insurance solutions, personalized service

List of Services: Various insurance products

Company Highlights: Focus on meeting unique client needs

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Not specified

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: Hurley Insurance Group's commitment to personalized service ensures that clients receive insurance solutions tailored to their specific requirements. Their dedication to understanding individual needs sets them apart in the Fayetteville insurance market.

7. Warren Insurance Group - A Mike Warren Agency

Company Summary: Warren Insurance Group, led by Mike Warren, is an independent agency committed to providing personalized insurance solutions. They offer a variety of insurance products tailored to meet the unique needs of their clients.

Official Website: https://warreninsgroup.com/

Physical Address: 1909 Bragg Blvd Ste 102A, Fayetteville, NC 28303

Contact Number: +1 910-222-2588

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: Not specified

Founder Name: Mike Warren

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Personalized service and a wide range of insurance products

List of Services: Auto, home, business, and life insurance

Company Highlights: Independent agency offering tailored insurance solutions

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Not specified

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: Warren Insurance Group, under the leadership of Mike Warren, provides personalized insurance solutions to meet the diverse needs of their clients. As an independent agency, they offer a variety of insurance products tailored to individual requirements.

8. Hurley Insurance Group

Company Summary: Hurley Insurance Group is dedicated to offering comprehensive insurance solutions with a focus on customer satisfaction. Their experienced team provides personalized service to ensure clients receive the coverage they need.

Official Website: https://hurleyinsurancegroup.com/

Physical Address: 1653 Owen Dr, Fayetteville, NC 28304

Contact Number: +1 910-221-3500

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: Not specified

Founder Name: Not specified

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Comprehensive coverage options and personalized service

List of Services: Auto, home, business, and life insurance

Company Highlights: Focus on customer satisfaction and tailored insurance solutions

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Not specified

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: Hurley Insurance Group is committed to providing comprehensive insurance solutions with a strong emphasis on customer satisfaction. Their experienced team ensures clients receive personalized service and coverage tailored to their specific needs.

9. AL Kerr Insurance and Associates

Company Summary: AL Kerr Insurance and Associates is an independent agency offering a range of insurance products to meet the diverse needs of their clients. They are committed to providing personalized service and comprehensive coverage options.

Official Website: https://alkerrinsurance.com/

Physical Address: 123 Rowan St, Fayetteville, NC 28301

Contact Number: +1 910-485-8849

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: Not specified

Founder Name: Not specified

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Personalized service and a variety of insurance products

List of Services: Auto, home, business, and life insurance

Company Highlights: Independent agency offering tailored insurance solutions

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Not specified

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: AL Kerr Insurance and Associates provides a range of insurance products tailored to meet the unique needs of their clients. As an independent agency, they are committed to offering personalized service and comprehensive coverage options.

10. Hurley Insurance Group

Company Summary: Founded in 1986, Hurley Insurance Group is an independent agency based in Fayetteville, North Carolina. They represent multiple insurance companies, providing clients with tailored coverage options at affordable prices. The agency prides itself on its experienced team, local roots, and commitment to excellent customer service.

Official Website: https://www.hurleyinsurancegroup.com/

Physical Address: 1653 Owen Dr, Fayetteville, NC 28304

Contact Number: +1 910-221-3500

Email ID: Not specified

Number of Employees: Not specified

Year Founded: 1986

Founder Name: Mark Hurley

Number of Reviews: Not specified

Coverage Locations: Fayetteville and surrounding areas

Benefits: Access to multiple insurance carriers, personalized service, and a deep understanding of the local community

List of Services: Auto, home, life, and commercial insurance

Company Highlights: Over three decades of service in the Fayetteville area, with a focus on building lasting relationships with clients

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients appreciate the agency's knowledgeable staff and their dedication to finding the best coverage options

Certifications and Awards: Not specified

Review: Hurley Insurance Group's longstanding presence in Fayetteville speaks to their commitment to the community. Their personalized approach and access to multiple carriers make them a valuable resource for clients seeking comprehensive insurance solutions.