Top 20 Insurance Providers In New Haven
Finding the right insurance provider is essential for protecting your assets, health, and future. In this guide, we highlight the top 20 insurance companies in New Haven, offering a range of coverage options, including auto, home, health, and business insurance.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f1f9b/f1f9bdd9ed879a6ffc34f350ddb98b7a17da1971" alt="Top 20 Insurance Providers In New Haven"
New Haven, Connecticut, is home to a diverse array of insurance providers catering to the varied needs of its residents and businesses. Below is a comprehensive list of 50 top insurance providers in New Haven, each accompanied by a detailed profile and review.
1. Main Street Insurance
Company Summary: Main Street Insurance is a family-owned agency dedicated to assisting New Haven residents with their insurance needs. They offer a range of homeowners' insurance products and collaborate with Hometown Insurance Agency to provide tailored solutions. Their services extend to personal, commercial, life, and health insurance plans. As members of the Renaissance Alliance and Associated Risk Managers International, they have a broad network to serve their clients effectively.
Official Website: Main Street Insurance
Physical Address: New Haven, CT
Contact Number: Not specified
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: Primarily New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Personalized service, diverse insurance offerings, and strong industry affiliations
List of Services: Homeowners, personal, commercial, life, and health insurance
Company Highlights: Membership in prominent insurance networks
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the personalized attention and comprehensive coverage options provided by Main Street Insurance.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Main Street Insurance stands out for its commitment to personalized service and a broad spectrum of insurance products. Their affiliation with reputable networks enhances their ability to offer competitive and comprehensive coverage options to the New Haven community.
2. Insurance Problem Solvers LLC
Company Summary: Insurance Problem Solvers LLC is an independent agency serving New Haven and its surrounding areas. They provide a wide array of insurance solutions, including auto, motorcycle, watercraft, and recreational vehicle insurance. Their commercial offerings encompass business owners', general liability, builders' risk, and workers' compensation insurance. The agency represents well-known carriers such as Progressive, MetLife, Safeco, Travelers, Zurich, and Foremost.
Official Website: Insurance Problem Solvers LLC
Physical Address: New Haven, CT
Contact Number: Not specified
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding regions
Benefits: Diverse insurance offerings and partnerships with leading carriers
List of Services: Auto, motorcycle, watercraft, recreational vehicle, business owners', general liability, builders' risk, and workers' compensation insurance
Company Highlights: Representation of multiple reputable insurance carriers
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients value the agency's comprehensive service offerings and the convenience of accessing various insurance products under one roof.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Insurance Problem Solvers LLC excels in offering a broad spectrum of insurance solutions, catering to both personal and commercial needs. Their representation of esteemed carriers ensures clients receive quality coverage options tailored to their specific requirements.
3. L.H. Brenner Inc.
Company Summary: L.H. Brenner Inc. is a full-service insurance agency based in New Haven. They assist clients in accessing a wide range of insurance products, with a focus on homeowners' insurance. Their agents provide guidance on the best ways to insure homes and advise on potential concerns clients' properties may face. They also help identify and cover any gaps in existing insurance coverage.
Official Website: L.H. Brenner Inc.
Physical Address: New Haven, CT
Contact Number: Not specified
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and nearby areas
Benefits: Expert guidance on homeowners' insurance and proactive identification of coverage gaps
List of Services: Homeowners' insurance and related advisory services
Company Highlights: Dedicated focus on comprehensive homeowners' insurance solutions
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the agency's thorough approach in evaluating their insurance needs and providing tailored solutions.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: L.H. Brenner Inc. is distinguished by its meticulous approach to homeowners' insurance, ensuring clients are well-informed and adequately covered. Their commitment to identifying and addressing potential coverage gaps demonstrates a proactive stance in client advocacy.
4. Abbate Insurance Associates, Inc.
Company Summary: Abbate Insurance Associates, Inc. has been delivering insurance products and services in New Haven and nearby areas for over 45 years. The company helps homeowners secure their homes and personal properties against perils through a homeowners' insurance policy. Its homeowners' insurance plans may be extended to several types of residences, including estate homes, vacation homes, condominiums, and rental properties. Other services include personal, commercial, life, and health insurance plans. The company is a member of the Renaissance Alliance and Associated Risk Managers International.
Official Website: Abbate Insurance Associates, Inc.
Physical Address: 671 State St, New Haven, CT 06511
Contact Number: +1 203-777-7229
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and nearby areas
Benefits: Comprehensive coverage options for various types of residences and membership in reputable insurance networks
List of Services: Homeowners, personal, commercial, life, and health insurance
Company Highlights: Over 45 years of service and affiliation with industry alliances
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients appreciate the agency's extensive experience and the variety of insurance products offered.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Abbate Insurance Associates, Inc. stands out for its long-standing presence in the New Haven community and its comprehensive range of insurance services. Their ability to cater to various types of residences and affiliation with industry alliances enhances their credibility and service offerings.
5. JVR Insurance
Company Summary: Located in Connecticut, JVR Insurance provides insurance products and solutions to residents of New Haven and the surrounding areas. It provides homeowners' insurance policies to clients looking to secure their residential properties. It has a team of seasoned insurance agents capable of customizing home insurance coverage plans to ensure that clients' residential protection requirements are met.
Official Website: Not specified
Physical Address: Hamden, CT
Contact Number: Not specified
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Customized home insurance coverage plans
List of Services: Homeowners' insurance
Company Highlights: Team of seasoned insurance agents
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients value the personalized approach and tailored coverage options provided by JVR Insurance.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: JVR Insurance is recognized for its personalized service and ability to customize homeowners' insurance policies to meet individual client needs. Their team of experienced agents ensures that clients receive tailored coverage solutions.
6. Orlando Jackson Insurance Agency
Company Summary: Orlando Jackson Insurance Agency discusses insurance policy options to residents and business property owners in New Haven and the surrounding areas. The agents educate the clients on the different factors to consider when getting a homeowner’s insurance policy. These factors include the age of the home, the heating system used, and the area where the house is located. The homeowner’s insurance policy covers damages and loss due to fire, storms, theft, and vandalism. The company has been in the industry since 1980.
Official Website: Orlando Jackson Insurance Agency
Physical Address: 15 June St, Woodbridge, CT 06525
Contact Number: +1 203-387-1716
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: 1980
Founder Name: Orlando Jackson
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Educational approach to insurance and comprehensive homeowners' coverage
List of Services: Homeowners' insurance
Company Highlights: Over four decades of industry experience
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the agency's thoroughness in explaining policy details and factors affecting coverage.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: With over 40 years of experience, Orlando Jackson Insurance Agency is committed to educating clients about homeowners' insurance. Their focus on client education and comprehensive coverage options makes them a trusted choice in the New Haven area.
7. Thompson & Peck, Inc.
Company Summary: Thompson & Peck, Inc. is an independent insurance agency that has been serving the community of New Haven and nearby areas since 1927. Its homeowners' insurance policy covers the home, its structures, and personal property, which includes medical payments, personal liability, and damages to the property.
Official Website: Thompson & Peck, Inc.
Physical Address: 205 Whitney Ave, New Haven, CT 06511
Contact Number: +1 203-777-5743
Email ID: info@thompsonandpeck.com
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: 1927
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Comprehensive homeowners' insurance coverage
List of Services: Homeowners' insurance
Company Highlights: Nearly a century of service in the New Haven community
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients appreciate the agency's long-standing presence and commitment to comprehensive coverage.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Thompson & Peck, Inc. has established itself as a reliable provider of homeowners' insurance in New Haven. Their extensive experience and focus on comprehensive coverage make them a trusted choice for residents seeking to protect their homes and personal property.
8. Amity Insurance & Financial Services, LLC
Company Summary: Serving New Haven, Amity Insurance & Financial Services, LLC, offers a variety of insurance products, including homeowners' insurance. It secures individuals and families financially if they suffer losses due to fire, theft, and vandalism. The policy can also cover the policyholders if someone sues them due to an injury on their property. Insurance policies for renters, vehicles, life, and businesses are also available. Paul Amann, one of the firm's owners, is an agent who holds both CLU and ChFC designations.
Official Website: Amity Insurance & Financial Services, LLC
Physical Address: Not specified
Contact Number: +1 203-397-8051
Email ID: info@amityinsurance.com
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Paul Amann
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Comprehensive coverage options and experienced agents with professional designations
List of Services: Homeowners, renters, vehicle, life, and business insurance
Company Highlights: Agents with CLU and ChFC designations
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients value the agency's knowledgeable agents and wide range of insurance products.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Amity Insurance & Financial Services, LLC, offers a broad spectrum of insurance products to meet the diverse needs of New Haven residents. The professional designations held by their agents underscore their expertise and commitment to providing quality service.
9. Ciardiello Insurance Agency
Company Summary: Ciardiello Insurance Agency collaborates with multiple insurance providers, including Acadia Insurance, Connecticut FAIR Plan, and National General Insurance, to offer a variety of insurance products to clients in New Haven.
Official Website: Not specified
Physical Address: Not specified
Contact Number: Not specified
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Access to a range of insurance products from multiple providers
List of Services: Various insurance products
Company Highlights: Partnerships with reputable insurance providers
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients appreciate the agency's ability to offer diverse insurance options through its collaborations.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Ciardiello Insurance Agency's partnerships with multiple insurance providers enable them to offer a wide range of insurance products to meet the diverse needs of their clients.
10. Tzedakah House, LLC
Company Summary: Tzedakah House, LLC is a privately owned insurance agency serving clients in and around New Haven. The agency specializes in designing and implementing health insurance and employee benefit programs for nonprofit organizations and businesses. They also provide ancillary benefits, including dental and vision insurance.
Official Website: Not specified
Physical Address: Not specified
Contact Number: Not specified
Email ID: Not specified
Number of Employees: Not specified
Year Founded: Not specified
Founder Name: Not specified
Number of Reviews: Not specified
Coverage Locations: New Haven and surrounding areas
Benefits: Expertise in health insurance and employee benefit programs
List of Services: Health insurance, employee benefit programs, dental and vision insurance
Company Highlights: Focus on nonprofit organizations and businesses
What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Clients value the agency's specialization in health insurance and employee benefits, particularly for nonprofits and businesses.
Certifications and Awards: Not specified
Review: Tzedakah House, LLC's specialization in health insurance and employee benefit programs makes them a valuable partner for nonprofit organizations and businesses seeking tailored insurance solutions.
What's Your Reaction?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/07a00/07a00b374a7e8d0ffd74b732eea78dca72e0184d" alt="like"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a9cb/5a9cba46c6336d1e9f804ca834256bc356de3e69" alt="dislike"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a624/5a624515ca1ad96aa9b058aae3ac9aa3df7246cc" alt="love"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c602/1c602b0a844999bf94177d280e5a823ac87d9645" alt="funny"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/013bd/013bd6fe84b89b564c68001190124e8ae7fbc589" alt="angry"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/98afd/98afd0292924b960a23811c4bc2fb4a898a79633" alt="sad"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/02541/02541581c209e83d4a9f4b95be5c8099ab72c80e" alt="wow"