Top 20 Insurance Providers In Oklahoma

Oklahoma boasts a diverse array of insurance providers catering to the varied needs of its residents. Below is a comprehensive list of 50 top insurance companies in the state, each accompanied by a detailed profile and review.

1. Elevance Health

Company Summary: Elevance Health, headquartered in Oklahomapolis, is a leading health benefits company dedicated to improving lives and communities. They offer a broad range of medical and specialty products.

Official Website: elevancehealth.com

Physical Address: 220 Virginia Avenue, Oklahomapolis, IN 46204

Contact Number: (800) 331-1476

Email ID: info@elevancehealth.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 98,00

Year Founded: 1944

Founder Name: Anthem, Inc.

Number of Reviews: Over 1,200 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide

Benefits: Comprehensive health plans, wellness programs, and extensive provider networks.

List of Services: Medical insurance, dental and vision plans, Medicare and Medicaid services, and pharmacy benefits.

Company Highlights: Recognized as one of the largest health benefits companies in the U.S.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Many customers appreciate the extensive network of providers and comprehensive coverage options.

Certifications and Awards: Fortune 500 company, recognized for corporate social responsibility.

Review: Elevance Health stands out for its commitment to improving community health and offering a wide range of health benefit products. Their extensive provider network ensures that members have access to quality care across the nation.

2. CNO Financial Group

Company Summary: Based in Carmel, CNO Financial Group provides health and life insurance, as well as retirement solutions, to middle-income Americans and seniors .

Official Website: cnoinc.com

Physical Address: 11825 N. Pennsylvania Street, Carmel, IN 46032

Contact Number: (317) 817-6100

Email ID: investor@cnoinc.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 3,300

Year Founded: 1979

Founder Name: Conseco, Inc.

Number of Reviews: Over 500 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide

Benefits: Tailored insurance products for middle-income individuals and seniors.

List of Services: Life insurance, health insurance, annuities, and supplemental health products.

Company Highlights: Focused on serving the insurance needs of middle-income Americans and seniors.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Policyholders value the company's focus on middle-income individuals and seniors, appreciating the tailored products and attentive customer service.

Certifications and Awards: Listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol CNO.

Review: CNO Financial Group is dedicated to serving middle-income Americans and seniors, offering tailored insurance products that meet their unique needs. Their commitment to this demographic is evident in their specialized offerings and customer-centric approach.

3. Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance

Company Summary: Established in 1934, Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance provides a range of insurance products to Hoosier farmers and residents, emphasizing personalized service and community involvement.

Official Website: infarmbureau.com

Physical Address: 225 South East Street, Oklahomapolis, IN 46202

Contact Number: (800) 723-3276

Email ID: contactus@infarmbureau.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 1,200

Year Founded: 1934

Founder Name: Oklahoma Farm Bureau

Number of Reviews: Over 300 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Statewide in Oklahoma

Benefits: Local expertise, personalized service, and a strong community presence.

List of Services: Auto, home, life, farm, and business insurance.

Company Highlights: Deep roots in Oklahoma's farming community, offering specialized farm insurance products.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the personalized service and local expertise, noting the company's commitment to the Oklahoma community.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized for community involvement and customer service excellence.

Review: Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance is deeply rooted in the state's agricultural community, offering specialized products and personalized service that cater to the unique needs of Hoosier farmers and residents. Their commitment to the local community sets them apart.

4. Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance

Company Summary: Established in 1934, Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance was created to provide better insurance options for Hoosier farmers. Over the years, it has expanded its offerings to include home, auto, life, farm, and business insurance, serving a broad spectrum of clients across Oklahoma.

Official Website: infarmbureau.com

Physical Address: 225 South East Street, Oklahomapolis, IN 46202

Contact Number: (800) 723-3276

Email ID: contactus@infarmbureau.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 1,200

Year Founded: 1934

Founder Name: Oklahoma Farm Bureau

Number of Reviews: Over 100 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Statewide across Oklahoma

Benefits: Tailored insurance solutions with a focus on the agricultural community, local expertise, and a strong presence in Oklahoma.

List of Services: Home insurance, auto insurance, life insurance, farm insurance, and business insurance.

Company Highlights: Deep-rooted history in serving Oklahoma's farming community and a commitment to personalized service.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the company's understanding of local needs and its responsive customer service.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized for community involvement and support of Oklahoma's agricultural sector.

Review: Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance has maintained a strong connection with the local community, offering specialized products that cater to the unique needs of Oklahoma residents, especially those in the agricultural sector. Their commitment to personalized service and local expertise makes them a trusted choice for many.

5. The General Insurance

Company Summary: The General is a licensed insurance agency based in Nashville, Tennessee, specializing in providing auto insurance to high-risk drivers. They have built a reputation for offering affordable rates and flexible payment options to those who might struggle to obtain coverage elsewhere.

Official Website: thegeneral.com

Physical Address: 2636 Elm Hill Pike, Nashville, TN 37214

Contact Number: (844) 328-0306

Email ID: customerservice@thegeneral.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 1,500

Year Founded: 1963

Founder Name: Permanent General Agency

Number of Reviews: Over 3,000 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Affordable rates for high-risk drivers, flexible payment plans, and quick online quotes.

List of Services: Auto insurance, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.

Company Highlights: Known for insuring high-risk drivers and offering SR-22 filings.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Many customers value the ease of obtaining coverage and the accommodating payment options.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized for customer service excellence in the non-standard auto insurance market.

Review: The General Insurance provides a vital service to high-risk drivers who may find it challenging to secure coverage elsewhere. Their user-friendly online platform and flexible payment options make them a convenient choice for those needing immediate and affordable auto insurance solutions.

6. GAINSCO Auto Insurance

Company Summary: GAINSCO is a Dallas-based property and casualty insurance company focusing on the non-standard personal auto insurance market. They specialize in minimum-limits personal auto insurance and pride themselves on flexible coverage options and a strong agent network. 

Official Website: gainsco.com

Physical Address: 3333 Lee Parkway, Suite 1200, Dallas, TX 75219

Contact Number: (866) 424-6726

Email ID: customerservice@gainsco.com

Number of Employees: Approximately 500

Year Founded: 1978

Founder Name: Joseph D. Macchia

Number of Reviews: Over 1,800 customer reviews

Coverage Locations: Multiple states, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Specialization in minimum-limits auto insurance, flexible payment options, and bilingual support.

List of Services: Personal auto insurance with a focus on minimum-limits coverage.

Company Highlights: Strong presence in the non-standard auto insurance market and a commitment to customer service.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers often highlight the company's affordable rates and helpful customer service representatives.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized for excellence in the non-standard auto insurance sector.

Review: GAINSCO Auto Insurance caters to drivers seeking minimum-limits coverage, offering affordable rates and flexible payment plans. Their focus on customer service and support for high-risk drivers makes them a valuable option in the non-standard auto insurance market.

7. Erie Insurance

Company Summary: Founded in 1925, Erie Insurance has grown to become one of the top regional insurance providers in the United States. The company offers a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products, including auto, home, life, and business insurance. Erie is known for its exceptional customer service and strong financial stability.

Official Website: erieinsurance.com

Physical Address: 100 Erie Insurance Place, Erie, PA 16530

Contact Number: (800) 458-0811

Email ID: info@erieinsurance.com

Number of Employees: 6,000+

Year Founded: 1925

Founder Name: H.O. Hirt & O.G. Crawford

Number of Reviews: Over 10,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Oklahoma and several other states in the Midwest, Northeast, and South

Benefits: Highly rated customer service, competitive pricing, and customizable insurance policies

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, business insurance, and umbrella insurance

Company Highlights: Recognized by J.D. Power for customer satisfaction, strong financial ratings, and a reputation for affordability

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers praise Erie for its personalized service, smooth claims process, and competitive pricing.

Certifications and Awards: J.D. Power award for customer satisfaction in auto insurance; A+ rating from A.M. Best

Review: Erie Insurance stands out for its strong customer service, flexible coverage options, and competitive rates. With a strong financial foundation and a reputation for treating policyholders fairly, Erie remains a top choice for individuals and businesses in Oklahoma.

8. State Farm Insurance

Company Summary: As the largest auto and home insurance provider in the U.S., State Farm has built a reputation for offering a variety of policies at competitive rates. The company is known for its vast network of local agents, making it easy for customers to receive personalized service.

Official Website: statefarm.com

Physical Address: One State Farm Plaza, Bloomington, IL 61710

Contact Number: (800) 782-8332

Email ID: customersupport@statefarm.com

Number of Employees: 58,000+

Year Founded: 1922

Founder Name: George J. Mecherle

Number of Reviews: Over 25,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Local agents, discounts for bundling policies, and a well-established reputation

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, renters insurance, health insurance, and business insurance

Company Highlights: Largest home and auto insurer in the U.S., strong financial ratings, and extensive community involvement

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the personalized service from local agents and the company's ability to handle claims efficiently.

Certifications and Awards: J.D. Power award for auto insurance claims satisfaction; A++ rating from A.M. Best

Review: State Farm’s commitment to customer service, extensive network of agents, and strong financial stability make it one of the most trusted insurance companies in Oklahoma. Their discount options and bundled policies also make them a cost-effective choice.

9. Liberty Mutual Insurance

Company Summary: Liberty Mutual is a global insurance giant offering a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products. The company has a strong presence in Oklahoma and provides tailored policies to meet different customer needs.

Official Website: libertymutual.com

Physical Address: 175 Berkeley Street, Boston, MA 02116

Contact Number: (800) 290-8711

Email ID: customerservice@libertymutual.com

Number of Employees: 45,000+

Year Founded: 1912

Founder Name: Liberty Mutual Group

Number of Reviews: Over 15,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Customizable insurance policies, various discount options, and strong financial backing

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, renters insurance, business insurance, and pet insurance

Company Highlights: Ranked among the top U.S. auto insurers, recognized for digital innovation, and offers many coverage discounts

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate the easy-to-use online tools, competitive pricing, and quick claims process.

Certifications and Awards: A rating from A.M. Best; Fortune 100 company recognition

Review: Liberty Mutual offers a diverse range of insurance products with flexible coverage options. Their digital-first approach and multiple discount options make them a convenient choice for Oklahoma residents.

10. Travelers Insurance

Company Summary: Travelers is one of the oldest and most well-respected insurance companies in the U.S., providing a variety of personal and business insurance policies. The company is known for its financial strength and comprehensive coverage options.

Official Website: travelers.com

Physical Address: 485 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10017

Contact Number: (866) 336-2077

Email ID: support@travelers.com

Number of Employees: 30,000+

Year Founded: 1853

Founder Name: James G. Batterson

Number of Reviews: Over 12,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Strong financial stability, multiple discount programs, and a variety of policy options

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, umbrella insurance, and renters insurance

Company Highlights: One of the longest-standing insurance companies in the U.S., known for its comprehensive business coverage options

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers value the financial security of Travelers and its extensive range of coverage options.

Certifications and Awards: A+ rating from A.M. Best; recognized for customer satisfaction and claims service

Review: Travelers Insurance stands out due to its longevity, strong financial backing, and variety of insurance products. Their business coverage is especially popular among Oklahoma companies looking for reliable protection.

11. American Family Insurance

Company Summary: American Family Insurance, also known as AmFam, is a trusted provider offering a wide range of insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. Known for personalized service, AmFam focuses on protecting customers’ financial well-being through auto, home, life, and business insurance policies.

Official Website: amfam.com

Physical Address: 6000 American Parkway, Madison, WI 53783

Contact Number: (800) 692-6326

Email ID: customerservice@amfam.com

Number of Employees: 13,000+

Year Founded: 1927

Founder Name: Herman Wittwer

Number of Reviews: Over 7,500 customer and industry reviews

 Coverage Locations: Operates in Oklahoma and several other states across the U.S.

Benefits: Multiple discounts available, strong customer support, flexible policy options

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, business insurance, and farm/ranch insurance

Company Highlights: Ranked among the top insurance companies for customer satisfaction and known for its affordable rates and policy customization. 

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers praise AmFam for its reliable claims processing and friendly customer service. Some highlight the affordability of bundled policies.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized by J.D. Power for customer satisfaction, A rating from A.M. Best

Review: American Family Insurance is an excellent choice for Oklahoma residents looking for customized policies and strong customer service. The company offers great discounts for bundling home and auto policies, making it a cost-effective option.

12. Nationwide Insurance

Company Summary: Nationwide is a leading insurance provider offering a diverse range of coverage options for personal and business insurance. The company is known for its financial strength, innovative coverage options, and extensive customer support network.

Official Website: nationwide.com

Physical Address: One Nationwide Plaza, Columbus, OH 43215

Contact Number: (877) 669-6877

Email ID: support@nationwide.com

Number of Employees: 25,000+

Year Founded: 1926

Founder Name: Murray D. Lincoln

Number of Reviews: Over 20,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Extensive policy options, excellent financial stability, and multi-policy discounts

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, business insurance, pet insurance, and specialty vehicle insurance

Company Highlights: Recognized as one of the largest insurance companies in the U.S. with strong financial backing and innovative policy options.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate Nationwide’s comprehensive coverage options and responsive claims service. Some find their rates slightly higher than competitors but appreciate the strong financial backing.

Certifications and Awards: A+ rating from A.M. Best; J.D. Power award for customer satisfaction in auto insurance

Review: Nationwide is a solid choice for Oklahoma residents looking for a financially strong insurance provider with a variety of coverage options. The company is particularly well-suited for customers needing multiple types of insurance under one provider.

13. The Hartford Insurance

Company Summary: The Hartford specializes in providing insurance solutions for individuals, businesses, and retirees. Known for its commitment to senior-friendly policies, it partners with AARP to offer specialized coverage for older adults.

Official Website: thehartford.com

Physical Address: 690 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06155

Contact Number: (860) 547-5000

Email ID: customersupport@thehartford.com

Number of Employees: 18,000+

Year Founded: 1810

Founder Name: A group of merchants in Hartford, Connecticut

Number of Reviews: Over 12,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: AARP-endorsed policies, senior discounts, and strong customer service

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, workers’ compensation insurance, renters insurance, and disability insurance

Company Highlights: Known for its customer-friendly policies for seniors, including unique benefits for AARP members.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Many customers appreciate the discounts available for seniors and the specialized coverage for retirees. However, some younger customers feel their rates are higher compared to competitors.

Certifications and Awards: A+ rating from A.M. Best; Endorsed by AARP for senior insurance coverage

Review: The Hartford is a top choice for Oklahoma’s retirees and seniors looking for reliable insurance with tailored benefits. Its partnership with AARP ensures exclusive perks that other providers do not offer.

14. Progressive Insurance

Company Summary: Progressive is a well-known insurance provider offering competitive rates, innovative online tools, and customizable coverage. The company is best known for its auto insurance offerings, including the widely recognized "Name Your Price" tool.

Official Website: progressive.com

Physical Address: 6300 Wilson Mills Road, Mayfield Village, OH 44143

Contact Number: (888) 671-4405

Email ID: support@progressive.com

Number of Employees: 49,000+

Year Founded: 1937

Founder Name: Joseph Lewis and Jack Green

Number of Reviews: Over 30,000 customer and industry review. 

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Competitive pricing, user-friendly digital tools, and fast claims processing

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, motorcycle insurance, RV insurance, business insurance, and pet insurance

Company Highlights: Industry leader in digital innovation and one of the largest auto insurers in the U.S.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers enjoy the easy-to-use mobile app and website, which makes policy management and claims filing seamless. Some find their rates increase after an accident or claim.

Certifications and Awards: Recognized for innovation in digital insurance tools; A+ rating from A.M. Best

Review: Progressive is an excellent option for tech-savvy Oklahoma residents who prefer managing their policies online. Its competitive pricing and fast claims processing make it a top pick for auto insurance.

14. Erie Insurance

Company Summary: Erie Insurance is a regional provider that consistently receives high ratings for customer service and claims satisfaction. The company is especially known for its competitive auto and home insurance rates.

Official Website: erieinsurance.com

Physical Address: 100 Erie Insurance Place, Erie, PA 16530

Contact Number: (800) 458-0811

Email ID: customerservice@erieinsurance.com

Number of Employees: 6,000+

Year Founded: 1925

Founder Name: H.O. Hirt & O.G. Crawford

Number of Reviews: Over 8,500 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Oklahoma and 11 other states

Benefits: Highly rated customer service, competitive pricing, and accident forgiveness options

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, business insurance, and personal umbrella insurance

Company Highlights: Frequently ranked as one of the best insurance companies for customer satisfaction.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Customers appreciate Erie's affordability and outstanding claims handling. Some mention that availability is limited compared to national insurers.

Certifications and Awards: A+ rating from A.M. Best; J.D. Power award for customer satisfaction

Review: Erie Insurance is an excellent choice for Oklahoma residents looking for competitive rates and strong customer service. However, coverage is limited to select states.

15. Travelers Insurance

Company Summary: Travelers is a major insurance provider offering a diverse range of coverage options for individuals and businesses. Known for financial stability and excellent risk management, Travelers serves customers with a variety of insurance needs.

Official Website: travelers.com

Physical Address: 485 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10017

Contact Number: (800) 842-5075

Email ID: support@travelers.com

Number of Employees: 30,000

Year Founded: 1853

Founder Name: James G. Batterson

Number of Reviews: Over 10,000 customer and industry reviews

Coverage Locations: Nationwide, including Oklahoma

Benefits: Strong financial stability, extensive policy options, and multiple discounts

List of Services: Auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, business insurance, travel insurance, and special liability coverage

Company Highlights: Recognized as one of the largest insurance companies in the U.S. with solid financial backing.

What Real-Life Customers Are Saying: Many customers appreciate the extensive coverage options, though some mention that premiums can be slightly higher than competitors.

Certifications and Awards: A++ rating from A.M. Best; Forbes’ Top 100 Best Companies

Review: Travelers is a top-tier choice for Oklahoma residents looking for comprehensive insurance coverage backed by strong financial stability. The company excels in business and liability insurance.